How to Evaluate CMMS Solutions for Manufacturing (2026 Updated)

December 23, 2025
Dr.-Ing. Simon Spelzhausen

A manufacturing company's choice of Computerised Maintenance Management System (CMMS) is crucial. Maximising equipment effectiveness (OEE), decreasing downtime, and streamlining workflows are all possible with the correct system. Missed production goals, irritated teams, and squandered resources are all possible outcomes of choosing the incorrect one. To help you make an investment that pays off, this article offers a comprehensive methodology for assessing industrial CMMS options.

Why Manufacturing Companies Need a Modern CMMS Today

Manufacturing operations are distinguished by a strong reliance on machinery, complicated production lines, and strict goals for how much they produce. In today's world, unexpected outages aren't only annoying; they're a direct hit to the bottom line. A lot of places are still stuck on spreadsheets or old systems. This often means maintenance is a constant scramble, with people always putting out fires instead of being proactive.

A contemporary CMMS shifts your approach from a reactive "fix it when it breaks" strategy to one that emphasises proactive and predictive maintenance. A manufacturing CMMS, by digitising maintenance processes, offers the visibility and control necessary to plan preventative chores, monitor asset health, and streamline personnel assignments. This change is crucial for staying competitive in today's manufacturing business, which uses Computerised Maintenance Management Systems (CMMS).

What Is a CMMS in the Manufacturing Sector?

A Computerised Maintenance Management System (CMMS) is essentially a software tool. Its purpose? To gather maintenance data in one place and streamline essential processes. While Computerised Maintenance Management Systems (CMMS) are utilised in numerous sectors, their use in manufacturing is unique. Manufacturing maintenance software has a unique challenge: it must keep up with the unrelenting speed and intricate operations of a factory floor, unlike software used in real estate or general facilities.

In manufacturing, a Computerised Maintenance Management System (CMMS) acts as the primary system, connecting asset dependability with the smooth running of production. It keeps tabs on a wide range of things: work orders, preventative maintenance plans, spare parts stock, and the history of equipment breakdowns. As a result, this action directly influences key performance indicators, including Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE), Mean Time to Repair (MTTR), and the overall productivity of the facility. At the heart of each effective factory maintenance management system lies a single, critical element.

Key Criteria to Evaluate CMMS Solutions for Manufacturing

When you begin to evaluate CMMS solutions, it's important to look beyond a simple feature list. Manufacturing has specific needs that require a purpose-built platform. Here is a framework to guide your evaluation.

Ease of Use, Adoption & User Experience

A CMMS is only effective if your team uses it. A clunky, complicated interface will lead to poor adoption and incomplete data. Look for solutions with intuitive dashboards, simple mobile workflows for technicians, and a design that requires minimal training. Fast onboarding is crucial to getting your team up and running without disrupting production schedules.

Work Order & Maintenance Workflow Capabilities

Effective work order management in manufacturing is the backbone of any maintenance department. Your CMMS should make it easy to create, assign, and track work orders from start to finish. Key features include automated work order generation, real-time status updates across shifts, and the ability to attach photos, documents, and safety checklists directly to a work order.

Preventive & Predictive Maintenance Features

Moving beyond reactive maintenance is the primary goal. Your chosen preventive maintenance software manufacturer should support both calendar-based and meter-based (e.g., machine hours, production cycles) PM scheduling. For a more advanced approach, look for predictive maintenance CMMS capabilities that leverage IoT sensor data and machine learning to forecast potential equipment failures before they happen.

Asset & Equipment Management Depth

A typical factory contains thousands of assets, from large machinery to smaller components. An effective asset management software for manufacturing must provide a centralised database for all equipment. This includes detailed asset profiles, hierarchical organisation (e.g., production line > machine > motor), failure codes, and a complete maintenance history log for every piece of equipment.

Parts, Inventory & Spare Management

Waiting for a spare part to arrive can bring a whole production line to a halt. The CMMS should include a robust inventory management module to track stock levels, set automatic reorder points, manage supplier information, and monitor part consumption. This ensures technicians have the parts they need when they need them.

Integrations with ERP, MES, IoT, and Automation Systems

Modern manufacturing relies on a connected ecosystem of software. It is critical that your CMMS integrates seamlessly with your existing systems, such as your Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), Manufacturing Execution System (MES), and SCADA. IoT-enabled CMMS solutions that connect directly to machine sensors provide real-time data for condition monitoring and predictive analytics.

Reporting, Analytics & Compliance Tracking

You cannot improve what you cannot measure. A strong CMMS provides customizable dashboards and reports to track key performance indicators (KPIs). This includes downtime trends, technician productivity, maintenance costs, and the direct impact of maintenance on OEE. These analytics are vital for making data-driven decisions and demonstrating compliance with industry regulations.

Mobile CMMS for Shop-Floor Technicians

Technicians are rarely sitting at a desk. A mobile-first CMMS app is essential for on-the-go productivity. Features like QR code scanning for instant asset lookup, offline mode for areas with poor connectivity, and mobile access to work orders and safety checklists empower technicians to complete their work more efficiently right on the shop floor.

CMMS Evaluation Checklist for Manufacturing Teams

Use this CMMS evaluation checklist as part of your CMMS selection guide to score potential vendors.

Must-Have Features:

  • Mobile app with offline capabilities
  • Automated work order management
  • Calendar- and meter-based preventive maintenance scheduling
  • Centralised asset database with full history
  • Spare parts and inventory management
  • Customizable reporting and KPI dashboards

Should-Have Features:

  • Pre-built integration with common ERP and MES platforms
  • Predictive maintenance capabilities (IoT/sensor data)
  • QR code/barcode scanning for assets and parts
  • Multi-site support for managing several plants
  • Customizable forms and checklists

Nice-to-Have Features:

  • Advanced analytics with AI-driven recommendations
  • Augmented reality (AR) support for remote assistance
  • Multi-language support for global teams
  • Supplier and contract management

Red Flags to Avoid:

  • No dedicated mobile app or a poor mobile experience
  • A generic, one-size-fits-all platform not built for manufacturing
  • Hidden fees for implementation, training, or support
  • Lack of an open API for custom integrations
  • A user interface that looks outdated and is difficult to navigate

Comparing CMMS Software for Manufacturing (How to Shortlist Vendors)

With so many options available, narrowing the field can be challenging. For your CMMS comparison manufacturing process, start by eliminating any generic vendors that don't specialise in the manufacturing sector. The best CMMS for manufacturing will understand the unique pressures of a factory environment.

Focus your shortlist on 3-5 vendors whose platforms excel in three key areas: user experience (UX), integrations, and automation. In a factory setting, speed and efficiency are everything. A system that is easy for technicians to use, connects seamlessly with your production software, and automates routine tasks will deliver the highest return on investment.

Questions to Ask During a CMMS Demo

A live demo is your chance to see the software in action. Prepare a list of questions specific to your operational needs.

  • Can you show me how to automate PMs based on machine hours or production cycles?
  • Does the system integrate with our specific ERP/MES? What does that integration look like?
  • What is the typical CMMS implementation manufacturing timeline for a facility of our size?
  • How customizable are the reporting dashboards for tracking our KPIs?
  • What specific features does the mobile app have for technicians on the floor?
  • What kind of onboarding, training, and ongoing support do you provide?

CMMS Implementation Steps for Manufacturing Companies

A successful implementation is just as important as choosing the right software.

Step 1 — Assess Current Maintenance Processes & Gaps

Before you implement new software, document your existing workflows. Identify bottlenecks, data quality issues, and any barriers to technician adoption.

Step 2 — Define Manufacturing KPIs (OEE, MTTR, MTBF, Downtime)

Establish clear, measurable objectives for your CMMS. Align these maintenance KPIs with your company's overall production goals to ensure everyone is working toward the same outcome.

Step 3 — Prepare Data & Asset Tagging

Clean up your data. Validate machine lists, organise assets into a logical hierarchy, gather bills of materials (BOM), and import any relevant maintenance history. A physical tagging project using QR codes can streamline this process.

Step 4 — Integrate with ERP/MES/IoT Systems

Work with your IT team and the CMMS vendor to connect the software to your critical factory systems. This step is essential for creating seamless visibility between production and maintenance teams.

Step 5 — Train Teams & Continuously Optimise

Provide thorough training for all users, from managers to technicians. After launch, use the CMMS analytics to monitor performance, identify areas for improvement, and continuously refine your maintenance strategies.

Calculating the ROI of CMMS in Manufacturing

The CMMS ROI in manufacturing is measured through tangible improvements across the facility. A modern CMMS directly reduces costs by minimising unplanned downtime, which in turn increases production output. It also reduces labour waste, optimising technician schedules and workflows. Better inventory management lowers spare parts carrying costs and prevents expensive rush orders.

Most importantly, a CMMS extends the life of your critical assets by shifting maintenance from reactive to proactive. This leads to significant improvements in OEE and long-term capital savings.

Real-World Example: How a Factory Improved Uptime with CMMS

A mid-sized automotive parts manufacturer was struggling with frequent, unpredictable equipment breakdowns. Their maintenance team operated in a constant state of reaction, using spreadsheets and paper forms to track work.

  • Before CMMS: The plant experienced an average of 15 hours of unplanned downtime per week, leading to missed deadlines and high overtime costs. Technicians spent valuable time searching for asset information and spare parts.
  • After CMMS: After implementing a manufacturing-focused CMMS, the company saw a 30% reduction in equipment breakdowns within six months. Technicians could now scan a QR code on a machine to instantly pull up its full history and required parts. Preventive maintenance was automated based on machine cycles, catching issues before they caused a failure. This led to faster technician response times and a more stable production environment.

Next Steps — Evaluate Your Manufacturing Operations with Makula CMMS

Understanding how to evaluate a CMMS is the first step toward transforming your maintenance operations. The right platform will empower your team, increase asset reliability, and directly contribute to your bottom line.

Ready to see how a CMMS built specifically for manufacturing can improve your uptime and efficiency?

Transform Your Technician Workflow

Enable technicians to complete work orders faster, accurately, and safely with a mobile-first CMMS. Access checklists, asset history, inventory, and SOPs anywhere, anytime.

Request Your Makula Demo

See how Makula CMMS accelerates work orders, reduces repeat failures, and improves asset uptime with a mobile-first approach.

FAQs

What is a CMMS used for in manufacturing?

A CMMS is used to centralise and automate maintenance operations in manufacturing, including work orders, preventive maintenance scheduling, asset tracking, spare parts management, and reporting on KPIs such as downtime and OEE.

What features should manufacturers look for in a CMMS?

Manufacturers should prioritise mobile access for technicians, automated and meter-based preventive maintenance, strong work order workflows, ERP/MES integrations, inventory management, and manufacturing-focused analytics.

How long does CMMS implementation take in manufacturing?

Implementation typically takes between 4 and 12 weeks, depending on plant size, data readiness, system integrations, and training requirements.

Can a CMMS integrate with ERP and MES systems?

Yes. Modern manufacturing CMMS platforms integrate with ERP, MES, and IoT systems to connect maintenance activities with production schedules, inventory, and real-time machine data.

Which KPIs does a CMMS help track in manufacturing?

A CMMS tracks KPIs such as OEE, MTBF, MTTR, planned vs. unplanned downtime, preventive maintenance compliance, maintenance costs, and technician productivity.

Dr.-Ing. Simon Spelzhausen
Co Founder & Chief Product Officer

Simon Spelzhausen, an engineering expert with a proven track record of driving business growth through innovative solutions, honed through his experience at Volkswagen.